News Releases

Recent Connection Between North and South America Reaffirmed

August 17, 2016

Long ago, one great ocean flowed between North and South America. When the narrow Isthmus of Panama joined the continents about 3 million years ago, it also separated the Atlantic from the Pacific Ocean. If this took place millions of years earlier, as recently asserted by some, the implications for both land and sea life would be revolutionary. Aaron O’Dea, staff scientist at the Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute (STRI), and colleagues writing in Science Advances firmly set the date at 2.8 million years ago.

“Recent scientific publications proposing the isolation of the two oceans between 23 to 6 million years ago rocked the generally held model of the continental connection to its foundations,” said Jeremy Jackson, emeritus staff scientist at the Smithsonian. “O’Dea and his team set out to reevaluate in unprecedented, rigorous detail, all of the available lines of evidence—geologic, oceanographic, genetic and ecological data and the analyses that bear on the question of when the Isthmus formed.”

“The timing of the connection between continents and the isolation of the Pacific and Atlantic oceans is important for so many reasons,” O’Dea said. “Estimates of rates of evolutionary change, models of global oceans, the origin of modern-day animals and plants of the Americas and why Caribbean reefs became established all depend upon knowing how and when the isthmus formed.”

The team of researchers from 23 institutions, including nine current or emeritus staff scientists from STRI and the Smithsonian’s National Museum of Natural History and 13 current or previous Smithsonian post-doctoral fellows concluded that records from marine and terrestrial fossils, volcanic and marine rocks and the genes of marine animals split by the formation of the Isthmus all tell the same story.

The study used three key pieces of evidence defined when the land bridge was finally in place:

  • Analysis of the family trees of shallow-water marine animals such as fish and sand dollars from the Pacific and Caribbean (Atlantic) sides of the isthmus show genetic mixing until after 3.2 million years ago.
  • Surface waters from the Pacific and Caribbean mixed until about 2.8 million years ago, as seen in deep-ocean sediments.
  • Massive migrations of land animals between North and South America began sometime before 2.7 million years ago.

The first paper to propose an earlier connection, published by Camilo Montes, professor at the Universidad de los Andes, and STRI staff scientist Carlos Jaramillo in 2015, asserted that tiny particles called zircons found in northern Colombia arrived there 15 million years ago via rivers from the Panama Arc along a land bridge. The authors of the new paper reveal that, in fact, there are several possible sources for these zircons, all of which require less convoluted travel to arrive at their resting place in the Magdalena basin.

The second paper to propose an earlier isthmus by Christine Bacon, post-doctoral fellow at the University of Gothenburg, suggested that molecular data from terrestrial animals and plants corresponded with geographic splits in marine animals, assuming the correspondence must have been due to a land bridge. The new study questions their use of a universal rate of evolution—“different species evolve at different rates,” Harilaos Lessios, a coauthor, said. They also question their use of genetic splits for land animals as evidence of the continental connection because “a land bridge would not cause genetic divergence, but would, on the contrary, allow greater genetic mixing between the continents.”

In addition, the new paper mentions that Bacon et al.’s study omitted several important published genetic analyses, which skewed their results and when included, eliminate the main line of evidence that marine and terrestrial events coincided.

The authors concluded, “Our review and new analyses aims to clarify the issue by bringing together expertise from a wide array of different lines of evidence. Given all the available evidence, we strongly caution against the uncritical acceptance of the old isthmus hypothesis.”

The Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute, headquartered in Panama City, Panama, is a part of the Smithsonian Institution. The Institute furthers the understanding of tropical nature and its importance to human welfare, trains students to conduct research in the tropics and promotes conservation by increasing public awareness of the beauty and importance of tropical ecosystems. Website. Promo video.

# # #

Reference: O’Dea, A., Lessios, H.A., Coates, A.G. et al. 2016. Formation of the Isthmus of Panama. Science Advances.

Author institutions include:

Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute
Texas A&M University at Galveston
University of Florida, Gainesville
Universidad Nacional de Colombia
U.S. Geological Survey, Boulder Colorado
Museo de La Plata, Argentina
Florida International University
University of Nevada, Reno
Florida State University
Scripps Institution of Oceanography, U.S. Geological Survey
University of California, Riverside
Universidade Federal Fluminense
Rutgers University
University of Iowa
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais
Hamilton College
Academia Colombiana de Ciencias Exactas
University of California, Berkeley
Natural History Museum, London
Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution
U.S. National Museum of Natural History
Washington and Lee University
University of Hawaii at Manoa
University of California, Davis

SI-409-2016

Media only 
Beth King
+507 212-8216
kingb@si.edu

Media website  
STRI News Releases

Computer generated aerial view of the isthmus of Panama
Related photos: 

Isthmus of Panama

Aerial view of a small isthmus

Jorge Aleman / Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute

A small isthmus forms in an island in the Panama Canal.

Photo: Jorge Aleman / Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute

Related photos: 

Isthmus of Panama: Basalts

Mists rising from ocean between large rock faces

Aaron O'Dea

Miocene basalts emerge from the ocean along the Pacific coast of the Isthmus of Panama.

Photo: Aaron O'Dea

 

Related photos: 

Isthmus of Panama: Columnar Basalts

Rock piles overlooking Panama Canal

Aaron O'Dea

Miocene columnar basalts that contributed to the formation of the Isthmus of Panama are removed for the expansion of the Panama canal.

Photo: Aaron O'Dea

 

Related photos: 

Isthmus of Panama: Darien

Shallow river with islands and mudflats

Laurel Collins

The Panama Paleontology Project navigates the Darien river in Panama, which contains Miocene marine sediments from one of the last seaways between the Pacific and Caribbean.

Photo: Laurel Collins

 

Related photos: 

Isthmus of Panama: Finger Island

Man next to rock outcropping

Aaron O'Dea

Paleontologist hunts for 7 million-year-old fossils on Finger Island along the Caribbean coast of Panama. The fossils found in this section share more affinities with Pacific faunas, suggesting the Isthmus of Panama had yet formed at this time.

Photo: Aaron O'Dea

 

Related photos: 

Isthmus of Panama: Isthmian pairs

Diagram showing similarities in Atlantic and Pacific species

Image courtesy Simon Coppard, Alexander Medvedev, Ross Robertson, Shellnut, Bob Fenner

Split by the Isthmus of Panama: Species of butterfly fish, sand dollar and cone snail that today live on the Pacific and Caribbean coasts of Central America are very closely related. Genetic sequencing shows that only 4 to 3 million years ago, each pair was a single species, demonstrating that marine connections between the oceans must have existed until that time.

 

Related photos: 

Isthmus of Panama: Miopliocene

photos of mollusk and coral fossils

Aaron O'Dea

Caribbean transformation. Before the Isthmus of Panama formed, nutrient-rich waters from the Pacific entered the Caribbean whose marine ecosystems were dominated by molluscs (left). When the Isthmus formed, around three million years ago, Pacific waters were blocked, nutrients declined and corals (right) became established across the Caribbean.

Photo: Aaron O'Dea

Related photos: 

Isthmus of Panama: Shrimp

Comparison of shrimp species on either side of the Isthmu

Arthur Anker

Snapping shrimp species on either side of the Isthmus of Panama are morphologically and genetically similar. Shallow water dwelling species are more closely related than deep dwellers, as would be expected by a slowly emerging isthmus.

Image: Arthur Anker

 

Related photos: 

Isthmus of Panama: Urumaco

Artists rendering of dinosaurs

Jorge Gonzalez

Reconstruction of a river delta in northwest Venezuela  9 million years ago. Fossils uncovered in the Urumaco Formation show the delta was home to a wide variety of animals, many of whom were giants, such as sloths,  rodents, armadlillos and crocodiles of immense proportions.

Related photos: 

Isthmus of Panama: Zircons

magnified zircon crystals

Angel Barbosa

Zircon crystals are like fingerprints holding clues of their source. For example, zircons found in 15 million year old river sediments in Colombia possess a signature like volcanic rocks on the Isthmus of Panama, which led researchers to believe that a land bridge must have connected the two realms at that time.



DCSIMG